Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Top 20-the girls sing

My thoughts on the girls:

Carly Smithson--"Crazy On You." She sounded much better than last week, but I agree with Simon. She hasn't picked 'that song,' yet. I don't think she is quite as amazing as Simon makes her out to be, but she gave a good solid performance. 7 of 10

Syesha Mercado--"Me and Mr Jones." So. Slow. She really did sound great, but this slow of a song may kill her. 6 of 10

Brooke White--"You're So Vain." Great song choice for her. The verses were great but when she went low, she kind of faded out too much. I like Brooke a lot. 7 1/2 of 10

Ramiele Malubay--"Don't Leave Me This Way." Eh. She could have been better. I'm not a huge fan. The girl can sing, no doubt about it, but I wasn't really blown away. And oh my do I ever hate her hair. 6 1/2 of 10

Kristy Lee Cook--"You're No Good." A good song choice for her, I think. She did much better this week but I'm still not a huge fan. I can't decide. Her stance on stage is kind of odd looking, too. 6 of 10

Amanda Overmeyer--"Carry On My Wayward Son." Bad from her hair to the last note. Not good at all. 4 of 10

Alaina Whitaker--"Hopelessly Devoted." Why must they choose slow songs?? It was just ok. 5 1/2 of 10

Alexandrea Lushington--"If You Leave Me Now." To soft and quiet. Didn't sound very good at all. 4 of 10

Kady Malloy--"Magic Man." Flat and quiet and not very good. She didn't belt it out like a Heart song needs to be belted. 4 of 10

Asia'h Epperson--"All By Myself." Pretty bad. 4 of 10

Wow! What a horrible night for the girls. I just pretty much ran out of things to say by the end.

My Top 3: Brooke White, Carly Smithson, and I guess, Ramiele even though I wasn't big on her performance.

My Bottom 3: Amanda, Alex and Kady

All screencaps courtesy of my boy, Slim.

posted by Angie @ 8:00 PM

2 Comments:

At 7:50 AM, DrillerAA said…

Ya gotta believe that Alex and Amanda will be exiting stage left tonight.
At 11:55 AM, Joyce said…

That's funny you would say Alex and Amanda because that's who exited Big Brother. I had to think twice when I read that, Driller. LOL